[情報] 2012/7/13 matousec 防火牆排名

看板AntiVirus (防毒)作者 (Roger)時間13年前 (2012/07/18 09:16), 編輯推噓1(106)
留言7則, 4人參與, 最新討論串1/1
http://www.matousec.com/projects/proactive-security-challenge-64/results.php (一)排名: 1.Comodo Internet Security Premium 5.9.219863.2196FREE 94 % 2.Outpost Security Suite Pro 7.5.2.3939.602.1809 86 % 3.Outpost Security Suite Free 7.1.1.3431.520.1248FREE 71 % 3.VirusBuster Internet Security Suite 4.1 71 % 5.Jetico Personal Firewall 2.1.0.10.2451 59 % 6.Privatefirewall 7.0.25.5FREE 56 % 7.ESET Smart Security 5.2.9.1 51 % 8.ZoneAlarm Extreme Security 2012 10.1.079.000 43 % 9.ZoneAlarm Free Antivirus + Firewall 10.2.064.000FREE 34 % 10.Kaspersky Internet Security 2012 12.0.0.374 28 % 11.Total Defense Internet Security Suite 8.0.0.87 21 % 12.avast! Internet Security 7.0.1456 15 % 13.Dr.Web Security Space 7.0.0.10140 11 % 14.Norton Internet Security 2012 19.5.0.145 10 % 15.Bitdefender Total Security 2012 15.0.36.1530 9 % 16.TrustPort Total Protection 2012 12.0.0.4860 8 % 17.Norman Security Suite PRO 9.00 6 % 17.PC Tools Internet Security 2012 9.0.0.898 6 % 17.Webroot SecureAnywhere Complete 2012 8.0.1.165 6 % 20.eScan Internet Security Suite 11.0.1139.1150 5 % 20.FortKnox Personal Firewall 8.0.205.0 5 % 20.G Data TotalSecurity 2012 22.1.0.0 5 % 20.ThreatFire 4.7.0.53FREE 5 % 24.Avira Internet Security 2012 12.0.0.832 4 % 25.Ad-Aware Total Security 21.1.0.30 3 % 25.AVG Internet Security 2012.0.1890 3 % 25.BullGuard Internet Security 12.0.218 3 % 25.F-Secure Internet Security 2012 12.44.110 3 % 25.K7 TotalSecurity 2012 12.1.0.119 3 % 25.McAfee Total Protection 2012 11.0.623 3 % 25.Panda Global Protection 2012 5.01.00 3 % 25.Rising Internet Security 2011 23.00.55.71 3 % --------------------------------------------------- (二)新增軟體 avast! Internet Security 7.0.1456 ThreatFire 4.7.0.53 Outpost Security Suite Free 7.1.1.3431.520.1248 ZoneAlarm Free Antivirus + Firewall 10.2.064.000 (三)官方評語: Except for avast! Internet Security, the products tested today are free of charge. Outpost Security Suite Free and ZoneAlarm Free Antivirus + Firewall are free versions of commercial products that we already tested in our challenge. ThreatFire is new to Proactive Security Challenge 64. Today's best score was reached by Outpost Security Suite Free. The same engine is being used in both the free and the Pro version of Outpost products. The difference between the free version and the commercial Pro version is that the free version uses slightly older version of the engine. This is why the protection of Outpost Security Suite Free is lower and so is its score – 71 %. Still a Good level of protection. ZoneAlarm Free Antivirus + Firewall finished with 34 %. This score is lower than the score of its paid version because some of the features of the paid version are not included in the free version – the protection against keyloggers for example. avast! Internet Security is the only product tested today that is not available for free. The results of its recently released major version 7 are exactly the same as those of the previously tested version 6, which means 15 %. On the field of protection features that are tested in our challenge, there are no improvements in the new version of avast!. ThreatFire passed few tests and finished with 5% score in the red zone among many others. http://www.matousec.com/projects/proactive-security-challenge-64/ -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.121.214.162

07/20 14:16, , 1F
我一直搞不懂這種排名目的是啥,有些是純防火,有些是純HIPS
07/20 14:16, 1F

07/20 14:17, , 2F
有些是防火+HIPS,這些東西放在一起比,很難有統一的標準啊
07/20 14:17, 2F

07/20 14:40, , 3F
我覺得PC tools可以自盡了..... 有HIPS還那麼慘烈
07/20 14:40, 3F

07/21 05:35, , 4F
其實我覺得只是rule的問題,如果每家都把預設的rule定的很
07/21 05:35, 4F

07/21 05:35, , 5F
複雜,要你一直按確認,自然排名不會高,但你會很煩.
07/21 05:35, 5F

07/21 07:10, , 6F
測試官方有寫了,不是用默認測試,而是用最高防禦設定。
07/21 07:10, 6F

07/22 16:50, , 7F
卡巴好慘
07/22 16:50, 7F
文章代碼(AID): #1G1Ww0oY (AntiVirus)
文章代碼(AID): #1G1Ww0oY (AntiVirus)